baydawg
2008-04-21, 01:59
In order to keep the grading objective and consistent as possible, each player received a grade relative to the round and slot drafted. Then, the EFS team received an overall grade based on the drafted players’ individual grades. I was a very tough grader, and I gave myself the 3rd lowest overall grade so don’t be mad at me for your grade. The overall grades where curved so everyone feels better about their selves. I know I needed the curve. The current NFL team will be listed for each selection if it changed, and EFS team grades will NOT be affected by trades (This is beyond the scope of this exercise).
General Rules of Thumb:
• Commentary will be provided for performance of players in 2005 and 2006, however 2007 stats will be heavily weighted on the player grade.
• Players will receive grades primarily based on there position rank in 2007. A player will be expected to perform at the level relative to his draft position. For example, if the BayDawgs drafted a RB in the first round we would expect him to be in the top 5-10 RBs for 2007. Similarly, if the BayDawgs selected a TE in the first round I would expect him to be in the top 3-5 TEs for 2007.
• Injuries will be taken in to account, but stats are the name of the game and will be heavily weighted.
Team Names Key
BayDawgs No Change
BroncoFan1407 No Change
Cant Stop Wont Stop No Change
creeping death No Change
Dark Dragons Da Cowboys
Destroyers Steilacoom Sentinels
Eternal Ramnation No Change
Just2Buff No Change
Raleigh Cerebrals CEREBRALS
Swollen Members II Raider Nation
The Program TOTAL DOMINATION
Timid Moose No Change
The Raw Numbers
• 32.1% of the players drafted in 2005 are now sitting at UFA.
• 17.9% of the players drafted in 2005 are with the same team that drafted them.
• Individual Draft Grades Given (ie there were 7 A+ given)
o A+ 7 8.3%
o A 5 6.0%
o A- 0 0.0%
o B+ 1 1.2%
o B 4 4.8%
o B- 6 7.1%
o C+ 5 6.0%
o C 8 9.5%
o C- 6 7.1%
o D+ 3 3.6%
o D 9 10.7%
o D- 3 3.6%
o F 19 22.6%
Top 5 Not Drafted in 2005
• Logan Mankins, OL, Pats, 24.0 pts/gm
• Trent Cole, DL, Eagles, 17.7 pts/gm
• Derek Anderson, QB, Browns, 29.1 pts/gm
• Chris Harris, CB, Panthers, 14.68 pts/gm
• Kelvin Hayden, CB, Colts, 13.68 pts/gm
Overall Team Grades (Alphabetical order)
BayDawgs, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Jason Campbell, QB, Skins
Worst Pick: Ciatrick Fason, RB, Vikes
The BayDawgs did not perform well. While Reggie Brown might still emerge, he did not produce to the level he should of being a #1 WR in Philly in 2007. Crowder has yet to get it at LB with the fins, but still could be a good one.
Round R# OA# Team Name Team Pos EFS Team Now Grade
2 10 22 BayDawgs Reggie Brown Eagles WR BayDawgs D+
3 3 27 BayDawgs Marcus A. Johnson Vikings OL UFA F
3 8 32 BayDawgs Channing Crowder Dolphins LB CEREBRALS C-
4 10 46 BayDawgs Ciatrick Fason Vikings RB UFA F
5 3 51 BayDawgs Jason Campbell Redskins QB BayDawgs B
BroncoFan1407, Overall Grade = C+
Best Pick: Kerry Rhodes, DB, Jets
Worst Pick: Maurice Clarett, RB, Broncos
BF1407 did not set the world on fire with his nine picks in 2005. He took big chances on RBs that did not payoff. Also, DL is a tough position to draft in later rounds. But, I have to give him credit for Kerry Rhodes in 5th round…Great Pick.
Round R# OA# Team Name Team Pos EFS Team Now Grade
2 4 16 BroncoFan1407 Alex Barron Rams OL CEREBRALS C-
2 6 18 BroncoFan1407 Maurice Clarett Broncos RB UFA F
2 7 19 BroncoFan1407 Eric Shelton Panthers RB UFA F
4 3 39 BroncoFan1407 Dylan Gandy Colts OL Cant Stop Wont Stop D-
4 7 43 BroncoFan1407 Matt Roth Dolphins DL creeping death D
5 6 54 BroncoFan1407 Dan Cody Ravens DL UFA F
5 10 58 BroncoFan1407 Kerry Rhodes Jets DB TOTAL DOMINATION A
6 7 67 BroncoFan1407 Ryan Moats Eagles RB UFA F
7 6 78 BroncoFan1407 David McMillan Browns DL UFA F
Cant Stop Wont Stop, Overall Grade = A
Best Pick: Braylon Edwards, WR, Browns
Worst Pick: Adrian McPherson, QB, Aints
No wonder CSWS has won the league the last two years in a row. CSWS 2005 draft was excellent. Only 2 players out of his 8 picks are not on teams currently. McPherson was his only truly awful pick, but it was a risk pick that did not pay off.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 5 5 Cant Stop Wont Stop Braylon J. Edwards Browns WR Just2Buff A
3 2 26 Cant Stop Wont Stop Carlos Rogers Redskins DB BayDawgs C
3 9 33 Cant Stop Wont Stop Barrett Ruud Buccaneers LB Timid Moose B
4 4 40 Cant Stop Wont Stop Brandon Jacobs Giants RB creeping death B-
4 11 47 Cant Stop Wont Stop Adrian McPherson Saints QB UFA F
5 9 57 Cant Stop Wont Stop Justin Tuck Giants DL Timid Moose A
6 4 64 Cant Stop Wont Stop Khalif Barnes Jaguars OL Cant Stop Wont Stop B+
7 9 81 Cant Stop Wont Stop Kyle Orton Bears QB UFA D+
creeping death, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Darren Sproles, RB, Chargers
Worst Pick: David Greene, QB, Hawks
Creeping death overall did very average in this draft. He selected average players in the slots he had, but his players could mature this year. I believe Rolle for one will flourish if the Cards do move him to safety. Matt Jones was always a bit of a risk and final could complete the transition from QB to WR this year.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
2 9 21 creeping death Antrel Rolle Cardinals DB creeping death C
3 4 28 creeping death Matt Jones Jaguars WR creeping death D+
4 9 45 creeping death Alex Smith Buccaneers TE UFA C-
5 4 52 creeping death Fabian Washington Raiders DB UFA D-
6 9 69 creeping death David Greene Seahawks QB UFA F
7 4 76 creeping death Darren Sproles Chargers RB Cant Stop Wont Stop C+
Dark Dragons, Overall Grade = B
Best Pick: Oshiomogho Atogwe, CB, Rams
Worst Pick: JJ Arington, RB, Cards
DD had a touch first couple of rounds, but recovered nicely with some late picks. DD’s gamble on Arington did not pay off, and is still waiting on Williamson and Clayton to dividends. Brodney Pool has yet to breakout by look for him to recover in a improved Browns’ D.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 4 4 Dark Dragons J.J. Arrington Cardinals RB creeping death F
1 11 11 Dark Dragons Troy Williamson Vikings WR Da Cowboys(Same) D-
2 2 14 Dark Dragons Mark Clayton Ravens WR Just2Buff D
3 11 35 Dark Dragons Oshiomogho Atogwe Rams DB Da Cowboys(Same) A+
4 2 38 Dark Dragons Brodney Pool Browns DB Cant Stop Wont Stop C+
5 11 59 Dark Dragons Darryl Blackstock Cardinals LB UFA D
6 2 62 Dark Dragons Alvin Pearman Jaguars RB UFA F
7 11 83 Dark Dragons Chris L. Canty Cowboys DL TOTAL DOMINATION B-
Destroyers, Overall Grade = A-
Best Pick: Lofa Tatupu, LB, Hawks
Worst Pick: Craphonso Thorpe, WR, Chiefs
Destroyers played it smart in the later rounds. He did not have a pick in the first 3 rounds but scored on some Tatupu and Marion Barber late in the draft. Spencer may have a solid year this year with the Hawks improved running game. The Destroyers has the honor of having no F grades of his players.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
4 5 41 Destroyers Kevin Burnett Cowboys LB UFA D
5 8 56 Destroyers Lofa Tatupu Seahawks LB Timid Moose A+
6 3 63 Destroyers Sean Considine Eagles DB Cant Stop Wont Stop B-
6 5 65 Destroyers Marion Barber III Cowboys RB Just2Buff A+
6 10 70 Destroyers Chris Spencer Seahawks OL TOTAL DOMINATION B-
7 8 80 Destroyers Brandon Jones Titans WR Timid Moose C
7 10 82 Destroyers Craphonso Thorpe Chiefs WR UFA D
Eternal Ramnation, Overall Grade = B+
Best Pick: Kirk Morrison, LB, Raiders
Worst Pick: David Pollack, LB, Bengals
ER did a good job in later rounds with homeruns on Brown and Morrison. I believe he snatched the best RB in the draft with Ronnie Brown, but time will tell. Parcells might have the Fins headed for a two headed attach in the future. I remember thing Benson would be the best RB of the group, boy was I wrong. I am glad I did not have the first two picks in 2005.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 1 1 Eternal Ramnation Cedric Benson Bears RB creeping death D
1 2 2 Eternal Ramnation Ronnie Brown Dolphins RB Cant Stop Wont Stop B-
2 5 17 Eternal Ramnation David Pollack Bengals DL UFA F
2 11 23 Eternal Ramnation Heath Miller Steelers TE BayDawgs C
5 2 50 Eternal Ramnation Jammal Brown Saints OL Eternal Ramnation A
6 11 71 Eternal Ramnation Kirk Morrison Raiders LB TOTAL DOMINATION A+
7 2 74 Eternal Ramnation Richie Incognito Rams OL Eternal Ramnation C
7 3 75 Eternal Ramnation Alfred Fincher Saints LB UFA F
Just2Buff, Overall Grade = B
Best Pick: Derrick Johnson, LB, Chiefs
Worst Pick: Mike Williams, WR, Lions
J2B missed on the WR of Mike Williams in the first, but recovered nicely with Derrick Johnson. The Chiefs are continuing to improve their Dline and with that DJ will get better. Marlin Jackson was a nice pick in the third, but everyone else draft was average.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 6 6 Just2Buff Mike Williams Lions WR UFA F
1 7 7 Just2Buff Derrick O. Johnson Chiefs LB Just2Buff B-
3 1 25 Just2Buff Erasmus James Vikings DL Da Cowboys D-
3 6 30 Just2Buff Mike Nugent Jets XK Just2Buff D
3 7 31 Just2Buff Marlin T. Jackson Colts DB Just2Buff B-
3 10 34 Just2Buff Josh Bullocks Saints DB Timid Moose C+
Raleigh Cerebrals, Overall Grade = B+
Best Pick: Shawne Merriman, LB, Chargers
Worst Pick: Odell Thurman, LB, Bengals
The Cerebrals first two rounds balanced itself out with homeruns on Ware and Merriman, but misses on Davis and Thurman. Overall the Cerebrals drafted well, but the top heavy draft did not insure him top picks in the end.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 3 3 Raleigh Cerebrals Carnell Williams Buccaneers RB Da Cowboys C
1 8 8 Raleigh Cerebrals Demarcus Ware Cowboys DL Eternal Ramnation A+
1 9 9 Raleigh Cerebrals Thomas Davis Panthers DB CEREBRALS D+
1 10 10 Raleigh Cerebrals Odell Thurman Bengals LB Just2Buff F
2 3 15 Raleigh Cerebrals Shawne Merriman Chargers LB TOTAL DOMINATION A+
2 12 24 Raleigh Cerebrals Vincent Jackson Chargers WR BayDawgs C
4 12 48 Raleigh Cerebrals Chris Henry Bengals WR Just2Bufff C-
5 1 49 Raleigh Cerebrals Larry Brackins Buccaneers WR UFA F
6 12 72 Raleigh Cerebrals Luis Castillo Chargers DL Just2Buff C+
7 1 73 Raleigh Cerebrals Mark Bradley Bears WR Timid Moose D
Swollen Members II, Overall Grade = A-
Best Pick: Frank Gore, RB, 49ers
Worst Pick: Travis Johnson, DL, Texans
SMII DT in the draft are a no-no Travis Johnson pulls down a very solid draft by the SMII, and what could have been 3 A grades in a row has been interrupted by PacMan’s (AKA Rainman) Vegas trip. Paterson is trying to prove my DT theory wrong and was a solid pick in the 6th.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 12 12 Swollen Members II Adam Jones Titans DB Raider Nation(Same) D
2 1 13 Swollen Members II Frank Gore 49ers RB Timid Moose A+
3 12 36 Swollen Members II Sharod White Falcons WR BayDawgs A
4 1 37 Swollen Members II Travis Johnson Texans DL UFA F
5 12 60 Swollen Members II Vernand Morency Texans RB Eternal Ramnation C-
6 1 61 Swollen Members II Mike Patterson Eagles DL Raider Nation(Same) B
7 12 84 Swollen Members II Jonathan Babineaux Falcons DL UFA C+
The Program, Overall Grade = C+
Best Pick: Roscoe Parrish, WR, Bills
Worst Pick: Marcus Spears, DL, Boys
When your best pick is the Bills’ 3rd WR you know you did not do the best job drafting. Frye looks to be a NFL backup, and Roby did not emerge in Memphis.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
3 5 29 The Program Marcus R. Spears Cowboys DL Steilacoom Sentinels F
5 7 55 The Program Roscoe Parrish Bills WR creeping death C
6 6 66 The Program Charlie Frye Browns QB UFA D
7 7 79 The Program Courtney Roby Titans WR UFA F
Timid Moose, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Michael Roos, OL, Titans
Worst Pick: Shaun Cody, DL, Lions
TM’s QBs might breakout this season, however to date they have done very little in this league. QBs need time to develop in this league. Cody and Murphy seem to be in no mans land with their respective teams.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
2 8 20 Timid Moose Alex D. Smith 49ers QB creeping death C-
4 6 42 Timid Moose Shaun Cody Lions DL UFA F
4 8 44 Timid Moose Aaron Rodgers Packers QB Steilacoom Sentinels C
5 5 53 Timid Moose Terrence Murphy Packers WR UFA F
6 8 68 Timid Moose Michael Roos Titans OL CEREBRALS B
7 5 77 Timid Moose Fred Gibson Steelers WR UFA F
General Rules of Thumb:
• Commentary will be provided for performance of players in 2005 and 2006, however 2007 stats will be heavily weighted on the player grade.
• Players will receive grades primarily based on there position rank in 2007. A player will be expected to perform at the level relative to his draft position. For example, if the BayDawgs drafted a RB in the first round we would expect him to be in the top 5-10 RBs for 2007. Similarly, if the BayDawgs selected a TE in the first round I would expect him to be in the top 3-5 TEs for 2007.
• Injuries will be taken in to account, but stats are the name of the game and will be heavily weighted.
Team Names Key
BayDawgs No Change
BroncoFan1407 No Change
Cant Stop Wont Stop No Change
creeping death No Change
Dark Dragons Da Cowboys
Destroyers Steilacoom Sentinels
Eternal Ramnation No Change
Just2Buff No Change
Raleigh Cerebrals CEREBRALS
Swollen Members II Raider Nation
The Program TOTAL DOMINATION
Timid Moose No Change
The Raw Numbers
• 32.1% of the players drafted in 2005 are now sitting at UFA.
• 17.9% of the players drafted in 2005 are with the same team that drafted them.
• Individual Draft Grades Given (ie there were 7 A+ given)
o A+ 7 8.3%
o A 5 6.0%
o A- 0 0.0%
o B+ 1 1.2%
o B 4 4.8%
o B- 6 7.1%
o C+ 5 6.0%
o C 8 9.5%
o C- 6 7.1%
o D+ 3 3.6%
o D 9 10.7%
o D- 3 3.6%
o F 19 22.6%
Top 5 Not Drafted in 2005
• Logan Mankins, OL, Pats, 24.0 pts/gm
• Trent Cole, DL, Eagles, 17.7 pts/gm
• Derek Anderson, QB, Browns, 29.1 pts/gm
• Chris Harris, CB, Panthers, 14.68 pts/gm
• Kelvin Hayden, CB, Colts, 13.68 pts/gm
Overall Team Grades (Alphabetical order)
BayDawgs, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Jason Campbell, QB, Skins
Worst Pick: Ciatrick Fason, RB, Vikes
The BayDawgs did not perform well. While Reggie Brown might still emerge, he did not produce to the level he should of being a #1 WR in Philly in 2007. Crowder has yet to get it at LB with the fins, but still could be a good one.
Round R# OA# Team Name Team Pos EFS Team Now Grade
2 10 22 BayDawgs Reggie Brown Eagles WR BayDawgs D+
3 3 27 BayDawgs Marcus A. Johnson Vikings OL UFA F
3 8 32 BayDawgs Channing Crowder Dolphins LB CEREBRALS C-
4 10 46 BayDawgs Ciatrick Fason Vikings RB UFA F
5 3 51 BayDawgs Jason Campbell Redskins QB BayDawgs B
BroncoFan1407, Overall Grade = C+
Best Pick: Kerry Rhodes, DB, Jets
Worst Pick: Maurice Clarett, RB, Broncos
BF1407 did not set the world on fire with his nine picks in 2005. He took big chances on RBs that did not payoff. Also, DL is a tough position to draft in later rounds. But, I have to give him credit for Kerry Rhodes in 5th round…Great Pick.
Round R# OA# Team Name Team Pos EFS Team Now Grade
2 4 16 BroncoFan1407 Alex Barron Rams OL CEREBRALS C-
2 6 18 BroncoFan1407 Maurice Clarett Broncos RB UFA F
2 7 19 BroncoFan1407 Eric Shelton Panthers RB UFA F
4 3 39 BroncoFan1407 Dylan Gandy Colts OL Cant Stop Wont Stop D-
4 7 43 BroncoFan1407 Matt Roth Dolphins DL creeping death D
5 6 54 BroncoFan1407 Dan Cody Ravens DL UFA F
5 10 58 BroncoFan1407 Kerry Rhodes Jets DB TOTAL DOMINATION A
6 7 67 BroncoFan1407 Ryan Moats Eagles RB UFA F
7 6 78 BroncoFan1407 David McMillan Browns DL UFA F
Cant Stop Wont Stop, Overall Grade = A
Best Pick: Braylon Edwards, WR, Browns
Worst Pick: Adrian McPherson, QB, Aints
No wonder CSWS has won the league the last two years in a row. CSWS 2005 draft was excellent. Only 2 players out of his 8 picks are not on teams currently. McPherson was his only truly awful pick, but it was a risk pick that did not pay off.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 5 5 Cant Stop Wont Stop Braylon J. Edwards Browns WR Just2Buff A
3 2 26 Cant Stop Wont Stop Carlos Rogers Redskins DB BayDawgs C
3 9 33 Cant Stop Wont Stop Barrett Ruud Buccaneers LB Timid Moose B
4 4 40 Cant Stop Wont Stop Brandon Jacobs Giants RB creeping death B-
4 11 47 Cant Stop Wont Stop Adrian McPherson Saints QB UFA F
5 9 57 Cant Stop Wont Stop Justin Tuck Giants DL Timid Moose A
6 4 64 Cant Stop Wont Stop Khalif Barnes Jaguars OL Cant Stop Wont Stop B+
7 9 81 Cant Stop Wont Stop Kyle Orton Bears QB UFA D+
creeping death, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Darren Sproles, RB, Chargers
Worst Pick: David Greene, QB, Hawks
Creeping death overall did very average in this draft. He selected average players in the slots he had, but his players could mature this year. I believe Rolle for one will flourish if the Cards do move him to safety. Matt Jones was always a bit of a risk and final could complete the transition from QB to WR this year.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
2 9 21 creeping death Antrel Rolle Cardinals DB creeping death C
3 4 28 creeping death Matt Jones Jaguars WR creeping death D+
4 9 45 creeping death Alex Smith Buccaneers TE UFA C-
5 4 52 creeping death Fabian Washington Raiders DB UFA D-
6 9 69 creeping death David Greene Seahawks QB UFA F
7 4 76 creeping death Darren Sproles Chargers RB Cant Stop Wont Stop C+
Dark Dragons, Overall Grade = B
Best Pick: Oshiomogho Atogwe, CB, Rams
Worst Pick: JJ Arington, RB, Cards
DD had a touch first couple of rounds, but recovered nicely with some late picks. DD’s gamble on Arington did not pay off, and is still waiting on Williamson and Clayton to dividends. Brodney Pool has yet to breakout by look for him to recover in a improved Browns’ D.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 4 4 Dark Dragons J.J. Arrington Cardinals RB creeping death F
1 11 11 Dark Dragons Troy Williamson Vikings WR Da Cowboys(Same) D-
2 2 14 Dark Dragons Mark Clayton Ravens WR Just2Buff D
3 11 35 Dark Dragons Oshiomogho Atogwe Rams DB Da Cowboys(Same) A+
4 2 38 Dark Dragons Brodney Pool Browns DB Cant Stop Wont Stop C+
5 11 59 Dark Dragons Darryl Blackstock Cardinals LB UFA D
6 2 62 Dark Dragons Alvin Pearman Jaguars RB UFA F
7 11 83 Dark Dragons Chris L. Canty Cowboys DL TOTAL DOMINATION B-
Destroyers, Overall Grade = A-
Best Pick: Lofa Tatupu, LB, Hawks
Worst Pick: Craphonso Thorpe, WR, Chiefs
Destroyers played it smart in the later rounds. He did not have a pick in the first 3 rounds but scored on some Tatupu and Marion Barber late in the draft. Spencer may have a solid year this year with the Hawks improved running game. The Destroyers has the honor of having no F grades of his players.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
4 5 41 Destroyers Kevin Burnett Cowboys LB UFA D
5 8 56 Destroyers Lofa Tatupu Seahawks LB Timid Moose A+
6 3 63 Destroyers Sean Considine Eagles DB Cant Stop Wont Stop B-
6 5 65 Destroyers Marion Barber III Cowboys RB Just2Buff A+
6 10 70 Destroyers Chris Spencer Seahawks OL TOTAL DOMINATION B-
7 8 80 Destroyers Brandon Jones Titans WR Timid Moose C
7 10 82 Destroyers Craphonso Thorpe Chiefs WR UFA D
Eternal Ramnation, Overall Grade = B+
Best Pick: Kirk Morrison, LB, Raiders
Worst Pick: David Pollack, LB, Bengals
ER did a good job in later rounds with homeruns on Brown and Morrison. I believe he snatched the best RB in the draft with Ronnie Brown, but time will tell. Parcells might have the Fins headed for a two headed attach in the future. I remember thing Benson would be the best RB of the group, boy was I wrong. I am glad I did not have the first two picks in 2005.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 1 1 Eternal Ramnation Cedric Benson Bears RB creeping death D
1 2 2 Eternal Ramnation Ronnie Brown Dolphins RB Cant Stop Wont Stop B-
2 5 17 Eternal Ramnation David Pollack Bengals DL UFA F
2 11 23 Eternal Ramnation Heath Miller Steelers TE BayDawgs C
5 2 50 Eternal Ramnation Jammal Brown Saints OL Eternal Ramnation A
6 11 71 Eternal Ramnation Kirk Morrison Raiders LB TOTAL DOMINATION A+
7 2 74 Eternal Ramnation Richie Incognito Rams OL Eternal Ramnation C
7 3 75 Eternal Ramnation Alfred Fincher Saints LB UFA F
Just2Buff, Overall Grade = B
Best Pick: Derrick Johnson, LB, Chiefs
Worst Pick: Mike Williams, WR, Lions
J2B missed on the WR of Mike Williams in the first, but recovered nicely with Derrick Johnson. The Chiefs are continuing to improve their Dline and with that DJ will get better. Marlin Jackson was a nice pick in the third, but everyone else draft was average.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 6 6 Just2Buff Mike Williams Lions WR UFA F
1 7 7 Just2Buff Derrick O. Johnson Chiefs LB Just2Buff B-
3 1 25 Just2Buff Erasmus James Vikings DL Da Cowboys D-
3 6 30 Just2Buff Mike Nugent Jets XK Just2Buff D
3 7 31 Just2Buff Marlin T. Jackson Colts DB Just2Buff B-
3 10 34 Just2Buff Josh Bullocks Saints DB Timid Moose C+
Raleigh Cerebrals, Overall Grade = B+
Best Pick: Shawne Merriman, LB, Chargers
Worst Pick: Odell Thurman, LB, Bengals
The Cerebrals first two rounds balanced itself out with homeruns on Ware and Merriman, but misses on Davis and Thurman. Overall the Cerebrals drafted well, but the top heavy draft did not insure him top picks in the end.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 3 3 Raleigh Cerebrals Carnell Williams Buccaneers RB Da Cowboys C
1 8 8 Raleigh Cerebrals Demarcus Ware Cowboys DL Eternal Ramnation A+
1 9 9 Raleigh Cerebrals Thomas Davis Panthers DB CEREBRALS D+
1 10 10 Raleigh Cerebrals Odell Thurman Bengals LB Just2Buff F
2 3 15 Raleigh Cerebrals Shawne Merriman Chargers LB TOTAL DOMINATION A+
2 12 24 Raleigh Cerebrals Vincent Jackson Chargers WR BayDawgs C
4 12 48 Raleigh Cerebrals Chris Henry Bengals WR Just2Bufff C-
5 1 49 Raleigh Cerebrals Larry Brackins Buccaneers WR UFA F
6 12 72 Raleigh Cerebrals Luis Castillo Chargers DL Just2Buff C+
7 1 73 Raleigh Cerebrals Mark Bradley Bears WR Timid Moose D
Swollen Members II, Overall Grade = A-
Best Pick: Frank Gore, RB, 49ers
Worst Pick: Travis Johnson, DL, Texans
SMII DT in the draft are a no-no Travis Johnson pulls down a very solid draft by the SMII, and what could have been 3 A grades in a row has been interrupted by PacMan’s (AKA Rainman) Vegas trip. Paterson is trying to prove my DT theory wrong and was a solid pick in the 6th.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
1 12 12 Swollen Members II Adam Jones Titans DB Raider Nation(Same) D
2 1 13 Swollen Members II Frank Gore 49ers RB Timid Moose A+
3 12 36 Swollen Members II Sharod White Falcons WR BayDawgs A
4 1 37 Swollen Members II Travis Johnson Texans DL UFA F
5 12 60 Swollen Members II Vernand Morency Texans RB Eternal Ramnation C-
6 1 61 Swollen Members II Mike Patterson Eagles DL Raider Nation(Same) B
7 12 84 Swollen Members II Jonathan Babineaux Falcons DL UFA C+
The Program, Overall Grade = C+
Best Pick: Roscoe Parrish, WR, Bills
Worst Pick: Marcus Spears, DL, Boys
When your best pick is the Bills’ 3rd WR you know you did not do the best job drafting. Frye looks to be a NFL backup, and Roby did not emerge in Memphis.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
3 5 29 The Program Marcus R. Spears Cowboys DL Steilacoom Sentinels F
5 7 55 The Program Roscoe Parrish Bills WR creeping death C
6 6 66 The Program Charlie Frye Browns QB UFA D
7 7 79 The Program Courtney Roby Titans WR UFA F
Timid Moose, Overall Grade = B-
Best Pick: Michael Roos, OL, Titans
Worst Pick: Shaun Cody, DL, Lions
TM’s QBs might breakout this season, however to date they have done very little in this league. QBs need time to develop in this league. Cody and Murphy seem to be in no mans land with their respective teams.
Round R# OA# EFS Team Name NFL Team Pos Current EFS Team Grade
2 8 20 Timid Moose Alex D. Smith 49ers QB creeping death C-
4 6 42 Timid Moose Shaun Cody Lions DL UFA F
4 8 44 Timid Moose Aaron Rodgers Packers QB Steilacoom Sentinels C
5 5 53 Timid Moose Terrence Murphy Packers WR UFA F
6 8 68 Timid Moose Michael Roos Titans OL CEREBRALS B
7 5 77 Timid Moose Fred Gibson Steelers WR UFA F